By – Amar Yumnam
During the second week of November 2026, I have had and still continuing the privilege and advantage of enjoying the social atmosphere, practically experience the social character from both structural and behaviouristic angles, and thusmentally admire the potential implications of lightening the financial pressures on local governance for social development.I will come to the Gujarat experience some time later, but for now let me focus on the Rajasthan experience in Udaipur. As of 15 November 2026, I have had the privilege of staying in a top hotel for two days and enjoy dinner in one of the most reputed restaurants for two days. Further, I have also enjoyed the fortune of visiting two tourist spots. I am definitely amazed by the direct implications and indirect spread effects of these. First, the single hotel where I have stayed with my family and children must be giving regular employment to at least two hundred fifty persons or so; I did not directly enquire to avoid any kind of possible guess about me by any of the staff members. Second, the annual linkages of this hotel with other service providers must be in value terms above Rs. 100 crores. Thus, the annual potential contribution from this single hotel to the exchequer of the Rajasthan Government in terms of taxes must be at the minimum about Rs. 10 crores. Now coming to the restaurant, it must be giving regular employment to about 115 persons by observing the number of customers it has to serve each day. In a year, it must be having turnover of about Rs. 15 to 20 crores. In other words, it must be contributing at about Rs 1 crore to the state exchequer.
Let us now turn to the tourist visits. The tourist places are mainly engaged in organising and controlling the tourist visits. The variety of services to be provided are lower in this than in a hotel or a restaurant. But any tourist destination would give employment to two kinds of population – one for security and another as tourist guides. Given this, any tourist destination would have around 150 to 200 persons who are dependent on it for livelihood for themselves and their families.But the larger significance lies in the thriving markets around sustaining the traditional crafts. Any tourist destination would have in the vicinity a trade worth at the minimum of Rs. 2 crores per day on any single day. In this, there is a large inflow of money to Rajasthan from around the globe.
Against these realities in a single city in Rajasthan, I have heard of fourvery discouraging things on Manipur during the last four days. First, there is the burning of harvested paddy. Second, four Nagas – one mother and her son and two siblings – were killed on a single day while travelling on a route the Manipur Government proudly claims as safe. During the recent spurt Naga-Kuki conflict, the number of casualties (meaning loss of lives) is about to hit a century. Third, there is a comment from the BJP on the formation of Committee for forthcoming elections by the Congress. Fourth, there are many comments coming out of the Indian bureaucracy taking excuse for the government of India to let unprecedented rise of ethnicisation and killings to take place freely in Manipur.
The Meetei-Kuki conflict as a medium for playing geopolitics in Manipur has failed. But the original objective of destroying the proud prevalence of a concept of civilisation with history continues to be the annoyance to the present conception of India. It is now fairly established that Manipur is nearly, if not completely, non-existent in the notion of India in the present Indian regime. Since the attempt to involve the Meeteis to score surety of destruction of the historical legacy, one form or the other of killings has to be encouraged to happen such that the world forgets the existence of a history with civilisation. As regards the comment of the BJP on the inclusion of one Professor is nothing more than an escapist attempt for diversion of attention from their failures. The constitution of an election committee is purely an internal affair of the party concerned. Is the problem to be concerned about by the BJP is the Professor’s issue or the utter failure to address the killings happening for the last four years? As regards the Indian bureaucracy’s” superior” attitude being tried to be shown as higher information, I would straightway counter them if they have done anything for development to override the insurgency? They need to know that information is not knowledge.But I would reiterate a question a friend repeatedly asks: what is the gain of India in excluding Manipur from the policy context?
Since the Indian democracy has no intention of inclusiveness for the “minors”, there is now a fundamental need for social discourse between Indian “elites” and people of the South East Asian part of India. On Manipur’s part, the clubs in the localities should be restored to the original order physically and behaviourally for most do not bear any semblance of it now. Since the people in the provincial government trades the peoples’ needs for personal benefits by dancing to the tunes of “Indian”, people of Manipur have to start anew the social discourse. Reorient Indian democracy.