Home » A contemplation on how to grow a good MLA in Manipur

A contemplation on how to grow a good MLA in Manipur

by IT Web Admin
0 comments 6 minutes read
A contemplation on how to grow a good MLA in Manipur

By – Leishemba Loushambam
Would you rather drink words dipped in honey, or words drenched in the blood of the Manipuris killed in the conflict? Speeches, it seems, have no effect on a land that can no longer grow grain and vegetables. Yet crowds still gather to listen to politicians with rapt attention, and the women of Ima Keithel still throng the market, selling the vegetables that somehow keep the state alive. A land of wonders now stands at the gate of a great festive ground, where the festival of democracy is about to be celebrated. This essay asks what it takes to be a good Member of the Legislative Assembly. So who is a good MLA? One who knows the worth of his or her seat, one among only sixty in the Manipur Legislative Assembly, and who treats it as a trust held on behalf of the people rather than a prize won for oneself. But to be a good MLA, one must first become an MLA, and that is where the trouble begins.

Commoners often complain that there should be a qualifying standard/exam for those who wish to contest elections. I think the greatest qualifying examination is the election itself. The candidate is the examinee, the voter is the examiner, and the result is announced from the counting hall. The difficulty is that the examiners are often poorly prepared. When voters do not understand how profoundly one election can shape the fate of a state, they cannot grade the paper properly.

It is hard to be a law abiding politician in the state, and harder still to remain one while chasing votes. Take a hypothetical case. A group of residents in my constituency is polluting a public lake. As a law abiding MLA, I must educate them, and if they persist, the law must take its course. But the law is enforced by the executive and judged by the judiciary, not by me. If the offenders are taken into custody and I then rush to the police station to secure their release, I have trampled on the other two pillars of democracy to protect my own vote bank. If I refuse, I may lose the next election. This is the real dilemma of a conscientious legislator, and it exists only because the public does not recognise the fault lines between the three organs of the state. The legislature makes laws, the executive implements them, and the judiciary interprets them. An MLA who bends the executive or leans on the courts for a favour is not serving the people. He is weakening the structure that protects them. Until voters see this, they will keep rewarding the wrong kind of “helpfulness” and punishing honest restraint.

Voters are also entitled to ask what MLAs did with the powers entrusted to them. Manipur has lived through a conflict in which more than three hundred people have died and some sixty thousand have been displaced, many of them still living in relief camps with little hope left. Throughout it, the legislators, who hold power granted by the people, too often seemed to be silent spectators or mere condemners of events. Within sight of the seat of government at Chingmeirong, where the tricolour of the world’s largest democracy flies, they have taken small and late steps to put government machinery, security forces and the state’s intellectuals to work.

Condemnation costs nothing. Power exists to be used. Every statement of regret from someone who held the means to act carries the taste of blood and tears. And such words still taste sweet in campaign season, because they are served in honey. These are not presumed words. They are observed ones.

Why does this keep happening? Because the examiners are too often befooled. When a vote is bought for two hundred rupees at one rally and five hundred at another, ideas are being sold off cheaply. Political analysts used to comment that a voter who sells a vote has no moral ground on which to demand a school, a hospital or a road five years later, but the question is not about schools, or hospitals, its rather about the guarantee of my next inhalation and exhalation .As winter and the festive season approach, voters should not be dazzled by gifts and blankets. A blanket lasts a season. A bad policy lasts a term, and a bad legislator can last a generation.

Voters should also give up the old habit of mistaking ritual for merit. Respect for elders is a fine tradition, and no one should discard it. But touching an elder’s feet at a campaign event is a gesture of courtesy, not a qualification for lawmaking. A candidate should be judged by what he proposes and whether it can be done. The questions should be hard. What reforms do you have in mind? What policies will you bring to the House? How will you fund them? A politician is meant to be a lawmaker, not a drain-cleaner. Fixing a clogged drain is the work of the municipality and the executive, and an MLA who builds a career on such small favours has chosen to be a contractor instead of a legislator. Sugar-coated activity is easy to stage. A sound idea, discussed thoroughly in public, is harder to produce and worth far more.

Above all, Manipur must refuse politics fought in the name of religion and caste. Both are personal matters and deserve respect, but they build barriers between people and have no business deciding elections. India today shows how deeply such divisions can poison public life, and my hope is that Manipur does not drink from the same cup. A state already wounded by conflict cannot afford more reasons to see its neighbour as a stranger. A candidate who asks for votes in the name of faith or clan is admitting that he has no policy to offer.

The contest must also be open to all. If only the wealthy can afford to stand, the economic hierarchy of the state will keep widening, and the Assembly will speak for the few. Society has a duty here. Families, communities and civil groups should encourage people of good intent and real policy ability to step forward. The open secret of dirty electoral politics has discouraged many capable people from entering the field. They look at the cost, the compromises and the abuse, and quietly stay home. When the good decline to contest, the field is left to those who never doubted themselves, and voters then complain about the choices they are given.

Honey tastes good. Honey mixed with blood must taste awful. It is next to impossible for a Manipuri to be a good, corruption-free MLA until the examiners, the voters, understand the realm of democracy. The responsibility is shared. Candidates must be willing to refuse favours that break the law, and voters must be willing to accept the refusal. Candidates must offer ideas, and voters must demand them. With the festival of democracy approaching, the ballot is the one instrument that every citizen of this wounded and beautiful state still holds equally. Let it be used to choose the one who tells the hard truth over the one who pours the sweetest honey.

Until voters see this, they will keep rewarding the wrong kind of “helpfulness” and punishing honest restraint. Being a good MLA and being an MLA liked by the majority of one’s constituency do not necessarily go together. The land will move forward only when people begin to like the good MLA, defined as someone who truly cares and can foresee the future of the state.

(The author is 2nd Year, Undergrad Research Student, Indian Institute of Science Education and Research, Mohali)

You may also like

Leave a Comment

Adblock Detected

Please support us by disabling your AdBlocker extension from your browsers for our website.