Hangover of lifting prohibition order

To many realists as well as moralists in Manipur, the adulteration of yoo (Local brew) is both an offence and a sin. The yoo itself is poisonous in the sense that it disturbs human beings biologically as well as socially; adding some other harmful elements for gaining extra profit is not only immoral but also an anti-religious act. In the context of consuming illicit and adulterated liquor, the Manipur Government, through its mouthpieces like Manipur Police and District Collectors, appeals to the public not to take ‘suspicious’ local yoo, reducing the entire problem of illicit liquor to the behaviour of individuals who cannot control their temptations, in Manipuri, mathibong waarakpa ngamdaba. The problem is much more than this individual behaviour around mathibong.

We may recall here that former Chief Minister of Manipur, N Biren Singh, while advocating lifting of the liquor ban in Manipur often expressed that the State could not control consumption of illicit liquor in spite of relevant laws enforced at that time. Many scholars who had supported the then Chief Minister of Manipur tried to convince the public that liquor selling at certain points as well as production and import of liquors through license will control the harmful effects on human body and social life; moreover, lifting the liquor prohibition will increase State Revenue. Many civil society organizations did not counter the government and government-sponsored statements except such organizations as Coalition Against Drugs and Alcohol (CADA), Imphal and a few local dailies. The entire argument in favor of ‘lifting prohibition laws’ lacked insight into the huge supplies of illicit liquor and corrupt practices of law-enforcing agencies including the Excise Department. The supplies come, even today, from different directions including Myanmar. As the State did not act to enforce the prohibition order, the problem of yoo was not properly addressed, except by the local voluntary bodies like CADA and Meira Paibis. No one is still fully convinced of the logic “if you cannot control, open shops on license” by oversighting the harmful effects of yoo (CADA once said correctly that there is no good yoo) on health and society.

Failure of law enforcement agencies even in the Post-Biren Prohibition Law, was set an example in the recent controversies over liquor-selling at the main gate of a music concert. The issue was not that the liquor selling was in a sports stadium, the issue is the permission of selling liquor outside the places which were identified by the Post-Biren Prohibition Law; the issue is over the public behaviour after consuming liquor. In short, is Manipur, a border state having porous borders and corrupt officials, ready for the lifting of liquor prohibition? Is tax collected from some agencies enough ground for lifting the prohibition? Or was the lifting in the interest of some businessmen?

The loss of valuable lives after consuming illicit liquor was a result of wrong government policy. And the loss was due to unchecked circulation of liquor commodities; meaning the officials were paid for doing their assigned duties. Moreover, the incident shows a serious error in the chain of public health centres; the failure to give minimum care to the victims before referring to higher hospitals cannot be blamed on the ill-behaviour of alcohol consumers.

The issue should be examined in a larger frame; the policy discussion should be reopened in the interest of public life. The two incidents over illicit liquor should not be considered only as sporadic cases; these cases are but fallout of untimely and anti-people government action in lifting liquor prohibition. CADA may initiate a larger policy debate over the emerging issues around the liquor prohibition considering the efforts by various civil society organizations including Nisha Bandh and Meira Paibis. The deafening silence from such strong organizations should be broken; a silence zone is not always encouraging. And the Government should not think that collecting samples for food testing is enough to suppress public agonies. Illicit liquor and the need for prohibition should not be looked from the food angle. If alcohol is considered as only a food item, will you call consuming substance use as a part of food habit or food culture? While cigarette and tobacco items are banned, what is the rationale for lifting liquor prohibition? Let us overcome the hangover of lifting the prohibition order. Who will move first: Meira Paibi, CADA, Imphal, or the Government?

Leader Writer – Sh Ajit

Related posts

RSS Chief’s Manipur Visit: Organisational priorities over a state in distress?

Manipur’s unending crisis: Seven extensions, no justice and fundamental rights in question

Upcoming Election, Accountability and the missing CIC